Trump administration asks Supreme Court to lift order blocking USPS mail-ballot restrictions
The Justice Department twice asked the Supreme Court to revive Postal Service mail-ballot rules a Boston judge blocked as ballots go out.
Objective Facts
The Trump administration went to the Supreme Court on September 3 seeking to lift a 14-day order by Boston-based U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani that stopped the Postal Service from enforcing a new rule on federal election ballot mail. The rule, which grew out of Trump's March executive order, would require states to submit envelope designs for review, add barcodes and upload voters' names and addresses to a federal portal. On September 4, Talwani issued a preliminary injunction, ruling that Congress never gave USPS power over elections and that the rushed rollout threatens disenfranchisement. Solicitor General D. John Sauer then filed a renewed emergency application on September 6, while the administration and 12 Republican-led states also appealed to the 1st Circuit. The challengers include Democratic attorneys general such as Massachusetts' Andrea Joy Campbell and voting rights groups, and the Supreme Court had not ruled as of September 6.
Left-Leaning Perspective
NPR's Hansi Lo Wang described the plan as having USPS check ballots rather than just deliver them, and he stressed a whistleblower report that the federal portal has not been properly tested and election officials' view that it is too late to implement. Democracy Docket's Yunior Rivas covered Talwani's injunction as a win for state control of elections and gathered Democratic reaction, including Nevada Secretary of State Francisco Aguilar, who said Trump's aim is chaos, and Michigan Attorney General Dana Nessel, who said such changes take months.
Right-Leaning Perspective
The Washington Examiner's Jack Birle framed the September 3 request as a time-sensitive procedural fight, recalling that the Supreme Court in August found a lower court lacked jurisdiction to block the government's effort to write a rule, and identifying Talwani as an Obama appointee. Fox News' Stephen Sorace led with the administration's case for the September 6 filing, including Sauer's warning about ballots already in the mail and the government's view that the rule leaves voter eligibility and ballot counting to states.
Deep Dive
The dispute traces to Trump's March executive order on mail voting and an August USPS rule that would condition delivery of federal election ballots on envelope design review, barcodes and voter lists uploaded to a federal portal. On August 24 the Supreme Court set aside an earlier injunction on procedural grounds because the rule was not yet final. USPS finalized it days later, Talwani issued a 14-day block, and the administration went to the justices on September 3, before Talwani converted her order into a preliminary injunction on September 4. The September 6 filing is the administration's third trip to the Supreme Court in the case, Fox News reported. The administration has a fair procedural argument: Jurist noted that temporary orders are not usually appealable, and the Examiner pointed out that the Supreme Court already found one lower court acted too early. Its weaker point is practical. NPR reported the USPS portal had no firm launch date and a whistleblower says it was not properly tested, and Talwani found no fraud record justifying a rule finalized under 70 days before the election. Challengers, for their part, say less about the government's claim that the envelope standards largely codify long-standing USPS recommendations. What comes next is quick. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson set a Wednesday deadline for responses, and the 1st Circuit is weighing its own stay request. Alabama begins mailing ballots September 9 and more states follow the week of September 13, so any ruling will land while voting is under way.