Trump administration proposes 2030 census overhaul that would stop counting immigrants without green cards

The Census Bureau proposed leaving noncitizens without green cards out of the 2030 apportionment count and dropping race questions.

Objective Facts

The U.S. Census Bureau published a proposed rule in the Federal Register on September 10, 2026, that would exclude foreign citizens who are not lawful permanent residents from the population count used to apportion House seats after the 2030 census. That group includes people in the country illegally and, according to The Washington Post and Democracy Docket, people with temporary legal status such as refugees and asylum seekers. The same rule would bar race, ethnicity and sexual orientation questions from the census form, while the bureau weighs a legal status question and greater use of administrative records from agencies such as the Department of Homeland Security and Treasury. Comments are due October 13, 2026, and the bureau has not yet issued a final rule. Legal challenges are expected, with New York Attorney General Letitia James and the ACLU both saying they are weighing court action.

Left-Leaning Perspective

The New York Times, in a story by Zolan Kanno-Youngs, focused on the loss of representation and funding for immigrant-heavy areas and on the end of federal race and ethnicity data, quoting Brookings demographer William H. Frey, who said the administration wants to leave out people it does not see as real Americans. NPR's Hansi Lo Wang reported that the plan rests on the claim that the framers did not intend to count these noncitizens, and he quoted ACLU attorney Adriel Cepeda Derieux, who said the 14th Amendment's text does not mention citizens or green card holders. The Washington Post's Amy B. Wang highlighted warnings from public health researchers that dropping race and ethnicity data would make health disparities harder to track.

Right-Leaning Perspective

Mainstream right outlets published little on the proposal between September 10 and 13 that this search could find. At Outside the Beltway, center-right blogger James Joyner wrote that he is open to leaving noncitizens out of apportionment but found the rule's description of who would be excluded vague. Joyner also doubted the plan would survive, recalling that Trump's earlier attempt failed in court and noting that Trump will not be president in 2030.

Deep Dive

The September 10 Federal Register notice turns a goal Donald Trump announced in August 2025 into a formal proposed rule. Trump's first administration lost a 2019 Supreme Court case over a citizenship question and failed to remove unauthorized residents from the 2020 apportionment numbers. This time the Census Bureau is rewriting its residence criteria, defining usual residence by where a person lawfully spent most days in the enumeration window and leaving out foreign citizens who are not lawful permanent residents. The same notice would bar race, ethnicity and sexual orientation questions from the census form while leaving the American Community Survey untouched. Critics quoted by NPR, the New York Times and Al Jazeera are on firm ground when they point to the 14th Amendment's text, which speaks of persons and has not been read to exclude noncitizens in past counts. They say less about the bureau's alternative argument, laid out in the Federal Register, that it has statutory discretion over residence rules, or about the fact that race data would still be collected through the American Community Survey. Supporters, as reflected in The Daily Wire's coverage, stress the political fairness argument but rarely address Census Bureau research, cited by NPR, showing citizenship-related questions can lower response rates, which could hurt accuracy for everyone in affected areas. James Joyner's point at Outside the Beltway that the rule is vague about which lawfully present residents fall out is a drafting problem that neither side has resolved. The next markers are the October 13 comment deadline, a required report to Congress on 2030 question topics, and lawsuits that Letitia James and the ACLU have signaled. Congress holds final authority over the census, and because the rule would apply after the 2028 election, its survival depends on courts and on who controls the executive branch in 2029.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

Trump administration proposes 2030 census overhaul that would stop counting immigrants without green cards

The Census Bureau proposed leaving noncitizens without green cards out of the 2030 apportionment count and dropping race questions.

Sep 10, 2026
What's Going On
  • The Census Bureau, part of the Commerce Department, published a proposed rule in the Federal Register on September 10, 2026, that would count only U.S. citizens and lawful permanent residents toward House apportionment after the 2030 census.
  • The rule would also bar questions on race, ethnicity and sexual orientation from the census questionnaire, and the bureau is seeking comment on adding a question about legal immigration status.
  • The Federal Register notice set an October 13, 2026 deadline for public comments, and the changes would apply after Donald Trump leaves office, so a future administration or Congress could reverse them.
  • New York Attorney General Letitia James said her office is exploring a legal challenge, and the ACLU told NPR it is considering a lawsuit, citing the 14th Amendment's language on counting the 'whole number of persons in each state.'
Far Left: Democracy Now said the plan would strip funding and congressional seats from areas with large immigrant populations, which tend to vote Democratic.
Left: The New York Times said the rule would only take effect after the 2028 election, leaving it open to reversal by a future administration.
Moderate: The AP reported that the bureau posted its reasoning to the Federal Register, saying people in the country illegally should not be part of the apportionment count.
Right: James Joyner said he sympathizes with excluding noncitizens from apportionment but objects to leaving them out of the population count entirely.
Far Right: The Daily Wire presented the rule as Trump delivering on his 2025 promise to exclude people in the country illegally from the census.
✓ Common Ground
Reporters at the AP, the New York Times and The Daily Wire all expect the rule to land in court, with the 14th Amendment's apportionment language as the central question.
Several writers across outlets, including James Joyner at Outside the Beltway and the New York Times, note that the rule would take effect after Trump leaves office, which leaves it exposed to reversal by a later administration or Congress.
James Joyner, a center-right blogger, and civil rights groups quoted by NPR share doubts about the rule's drafting, with Joyner calling its definition of excluded residents vague and the ACLU calling it at odds with the constitutional text.
◆ All Sources (12)
Federal Register - Decennial Census of the Population of Americans; Proposed Residence Criteria and Proposed Regulations for Demographic QuestionsAssociated Press (via MyNorthwest) - Under Trump, census eyes sweeping plan to omit immigrants, race dataAxios - Trump's census plan could reshape voting maps, eliminate race questionsAl Jazeera - Who is Trump trying to exclude from 2030 US census and why does it matter?The New York Times (via Hawaii Tribune-Herald) - Trump's census overhaul would exclude some immigrants and remove questions on raceNPR (via WUFT) - Trump officials revive a bid to alter the U.S. census and reshape voting mapsDemocracy Docket - Trump's latest plan to rig the congressional map for Republicans long after he's goneThe Daily Wire - Trump Admin Moves To Take Illegal Immigrants Off The CensusOutside the Beltway - Trump Wants to Exclude Millions from Census CountDemocracy Now - Trump Administration Proposes Overhaul of 2030 CensusThe Washington Post (via Jewish World Review) - Changes to censusAl Jazeera - Trump administration proposes excluding certain immigrants from US census
Objective Deep Dive

The September 10 Federal Register notice turns a goal Donald Trump announced in August 2025 into a formal proposed rule. Trump's first administration lost a 2019 Supreme Court case over a citizenship question and failed to remove unauthorized residents from the 2020 apportionment numbers. This time the Census Bureau is rewriting its residence criteria, defining usual residence by where a person lawfully spent most days in the enumeration window and leaving out foreign citizens who are not lawful permanent residents. The same notice would bar race, ethnicity and sexual orientation questions from the census form while leaving the American Community Survey untouched.

Critics quoted by NPR, the New York Times and Al Jazeera are on firm ground when they point to the 14th Amendment's text, which speaks of persons and has not been read to exclude noncitizens in past counts. They say less about the bureau's alternative argument, laid out in the Federal Register, that it has statutory discretion over residence rules, or about the fact that race data would still be collected through the American Community Survey. Supporters, as reflected in The Daily Wire's coverage, stress the political fairness argument but rarely address Census Bureau research, cited by NPR, showing citizenship-related questions can lower response rates, which could hurt accuracy for everyone in affected areas. James Joyner's point at Outside the Beltway that the rule is vague about which lawfully present residents fall out is a drafting problem that neither side has resolved.

The next markers are the October 13 comment deadline, a required report to Congress on 2030 question topics, and lawsuits that Letitia James and the ACLU have signaled. Congress holds final authority over the census, and because the rule would apply after the 2028 election, its survival depends on courts and on who controls the executive branch in 2029.

◈ Tone Comparison

Left and far-left outlets leaned on words like "rig" (Democracy Docket) and quoted Brookings demographer William Frey on who counts as American, while the AP and Axios relied on the bureau's own phrases such as "true inhabitants" and "colorblind." The Daily Wire used "illegal immigrants" throughout and led with Trump's pledge, and James Joyner's Outside the Beltway post read as wry skepticism of the drafting more than outrage or praise.