Trump administration's Title IX rule rescinding Biden-era LGBTQ protections takes effect
A Title IX rule erasing Biden-era LGBTQ protections and restoring 2020 rules took effect on publication September 29.
Objective Facts
On Tuesday, September 29, 2026, the Education Department published a final rule in the Federal Register that repeals the Biden administration's 2024 Title IX regulations and restores the 2020 rules from Donald Trump's first term, effective immediately, according to the law firm McGuireWoods. The 2024 rule had extended the federal ban on sex discrimination in schools to cover sexual orientation and gender identity, but a federal court vacated it in January 2025 and the department has enforced the 2020 rules since then. Education Secretary Linda McMahon said the rule makes the published regulations match court orders and congressional intent, PinkNews reported. Shiwali Patel of the National Women's Law Center and Human Rights Campaign president Kelley Robinson said the move weakens protections for transgender students and for survivors of sexual harassment and assault. Chalkbeat reported that the department plans a separate rule that would define sex as biological, which could have broader effects.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Defector's Diana Moskovitz and The Fader's Tobias Hess focused less on gender identity than on sexual assault, tying the rule to a lawsuit alleging a 2024 gang rape at Cornell University. Moskovitz argued that the department's enforcement arm has been gutted and that Title IX is now used mainly against schools with trans athletes. Chalkbeat's Lily Altavena reported that the department's announcement did not mention the rules' effect on harassment investigations.
Right-Leaning Perspective
In UnHerd, author Ben Appel called the revision a welcome return to biological reality and largely a formality, since a court had already vacated the 2024 rule. He argued that sex-based protections should stay distinct from gender identity and that Congress could protect gender identity in jobs and housing separately. Right-leaning outlets such as Fox News's OutKick and the Washington Examiner covered McMahon's announcement on Monday, September 28, the day before the rule took effect, and searches found little new right-leaning coverage after publication.
Deep Dive
The rule that took effect September 29 finishes a fight that courts had largely settled. The Biden administration's 2024 regulations treated discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity as sex discrimination, but they were tied up in litigation and vacated nationwide in January 2025. The Trump administration has enforced the 2020 rules since then. McGuireWoods reported that the department issued the final rule on September 25, published it September 29 and made it effective immediately, recodifying the 2020 text with four provisions dropped, including a cross-examination rule a court had already vacated. Critics are right that the 2020 rules handle sexual harassment differently: The Fader and The Week reported they narrow what schools must investigate and give accused students more procedural rights. Defector and The Fader tied that to a lawsuit over an alleged 2024 gang rape at Cornell, though the rule itself does not decide any case. Supporters such as Appel are right that the practical effect on gender identity is small, since the 2024 rule was already dead. What both sides tend to skip is the coming rule: Chalkbeat reported the department has said Title IX's definition of sex should refer only to biological classification as male or female, and Nixon Peabody said that rule could carry more direct effects for schools. Watch for that definitional rule and whether it gets a public comment period; Nixon Peabody expects it likely would. Schools that rewrote policies for 2024 now need to realign them with the 2020 text, Nixon Peabody advised. Sarah Parshall Perry told Chalkbeat the cycle of reversals is "regulatory ping-pong," and a future administration could reverse course again unless Congress acts.