Trump says he is ending Biden-era limits on methane from oil and gas drilling
Trump told a Texas rally he is ending Biden's methane rules for oil and gas wells, citing $45 billion in savings.
Objective Facts
Donald Trump said at a campaign rally in Lubbock, Texas, on October 27 that he was terminating the Biden administration's 2024 methane rule for oil and gas operations, a move EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin had previewed on October 7 at a New Mexico Oil and Gas Association meeting. The EPA's draft would eliminate the Super Emitter Program, which lets outside groups flag large leaks that companies must then investigate, and would loosen requirements for marginal wells and for flaring of gas at oil wells, according to the Associated Press and Reuters. Trump claimed the changes would save $45 billion and free up 210 million barrels of oil; the AP noted that Zeldin has put the cost of the Biden rule at $18 billion, while Biden officials had projected $98 billion in benefits using a social cost of carbon method that Trump's EPA rejects. The proposal still needs a public comment period and a final rule, and environmental groups including the Natural Resources Defense Council have signaled they will sue.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Mainstream left outlets put the climate and health effects at the top. NBC News reporter Evan Bush wrote that Trump gave few details at the rally and set the move inside a broader repeal of climate rules, quoting Liz Scott of the American Lung Association on the health risk from other pollutants that leak alongside methane. NPR and The Washington Post ran the AP account under a headline stressing climate-warming methane. Mountain West News Bureau reporters Jenny Kinsey and Austen Erblat, writing for public radio, quoted Aaron Weiss of the Center for Western Priorities arguing that keeping leaky low-output wells running would do little for prices.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Right-leaning outlets led with the cost and production figures. Daily Caller energy reporter Simon August wrote the most detailed account, citing the National Stripper Well Association's claim that compliance costs of $5,000 to $15,000 a year per well can exceed what the wells earn, and quoting Daren Bakst of the Competitive Enterprise Institute criticizing the Biden rules as inflexible. Fox Business reporter Sophia Compton built her story around the $45 billion and 210 million barrel figures. Washington Examiner reporter Maydeen Merino described the plan as an effort to raise domestic output and cut fuel costs a week before the midterms.
Deep Dive
The 2024 rule, announced by the Biden administration at the COP28 climate summit and finalized that year, was the first federal methane standard to reach existing wells, not only new ones. It required regular leak checks, phased out routine flaring and created the Super Emitter Program, which lets certified third parties report big leaks spotted by satellites or cameras. Trump's EPA delayed parts of it, Congress repealed the related methane fee early in 2025, and Zeldin previewed the replacement on October 7. Trump's rally announcement on October 27 brought the draft into the open, a week before the midterms and with Paxton, who first sued over the 2024 rule, in a close race. Supporters have a real point about scale and cost for small operators: the Daily Caller's figures show most U.S. wells are marginal, and per-well compliance costs can rival their revenue. Their coverage mostly skips the satellite research, cited by NBC News, Politico and AP, finding that these same wells account for a large share of oilfield methane. Critics are right that the $45 billion figure counts only industry costs and that Trump's EPA dropped the social cost of carbon method behind the $98 billion benefits estimate. Some critical outlets, though, lean on donor reports that rest on secondhand accounts, and few of them address whether the 2024 rule would have shut wells. The next step is publication in the Federal Register, which opens a comment period of at least 45 days and a public hearing. A final rule would almost certainly be challenged in court, with NRDC's David Doniger already predicting a suit. Watch for whether states such as New Mexico and Colorado tighten their own rules, as Earthworks urged, and whether a permitting bill co-sponsored by Sen. Martin Heinrich, due for a vote after the election, locks in weaker standards as public radio reported.