Trump says it is time for Ukraine to get a new president after diesel deal with Putin
A day after his diesel deal with Putin, Donald Trump said Ukraine should replace Volodymyr Zelenskyy with a leader who can make a deal.
Objective Facts
Donald Trump told reporters at the White House on October 10 that Ukraine should "get a new leader who can make a deal" and that it was time for a new president, blaming Volodymyr Zelenskyy for not ending the war and for strikes on Russian refineries that he linked to high US diesel prices. A day earlier, after a call with Vladimir Putin, Trump announced that Russia would supply diesel to US and global markets, and Zelenskyy said the deal rewarded Moscow. Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha said Zelenskyy has the backing of Ukrainians, and German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul, UK officials, Emmanuel Macron and Donald Tusk voiced support for him. In Washington, Republicans such as Thom Tillis, Don Bacon and Brian Fitzpatrick broke with Trump on the diesel deal, and a bipartisan group of 12 senators urged him on October 13 to rescind it. Russian officials welcomed Trump's call, while Ukrainian outlets emphasized that martial law rules out an election during the war.
Left-Leaning Perspective
The Washington Post reported that Trump's attack on Zelenskyy and the diesel deal drew criticism at home and abroad, quoting Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer accusing Trump of "doing a deal with the devil." The Post also noted that Zelenskyy said he would accept whatever leader Ukrainians choose and would hold elections if Russia agreed to a 60-day full ceasefire. NPR's Barbara Sprunt reported on October 13 that 12 senators, six from each party, called the deal "a gift to our adversary and a betrayal of our allies."
Right-Leaning Perspective
Just the News reporter Nicholas Ballasy ran Trump's remarks largely in his own words, including his claim that the war "started due to incompetence" and his call for a leader who can make a deal, with no Ukrainian response. Fox News Digital's Alex Nitzberg focused on Republicans breaking with Trump over the diesel deal, quoting Rep. Don Bacon that propping up Putin's war economy is "morally wrong." Fox's story covered the diesel deal rather than defending or attacking the call to replace Zelenskyy.
Deep Dive
Trump's comment came one day after he announced, following a call with Vladimir Putin, that Russia would supply diesel to the US and global markets, and as US diesel prices sat at record highs. Ukraine's Defense Ministry says its strikes have knocked out more than half of Russia's refining capacity, according to the Kyiv Independent, and Trump said those strikes were hurting American farmers. Ukrainian officials told the Kyiv Independent they had expected talks in Miami on a mutual energy ceasefire and instead saw Washington strike an economic deal with Moscow. Trump's defenders can point to a real price problem and to his long-standing view that Zelenskyy has been slow to accept a deal. That framing omits that Ukrainian law bars elections under martial law and that Zelenskyy has offered to pause energy strikes if Russia does the same. Critics of the deal, including Republicans like Thom Tillis, make a strong case that it sends revenue to Moscow, but some coverage ran together the diesel deal and the leadership remark, which drew less direct comment from Republican lawmakers. The next tests are Brian Fitzpatrick's push to force a House vote blocking Russian oil purchases, whether the administration answers the 12-senator letter, and whether European governments follow Kaja Kallas's pledge of new sanctions listings. Zelenskyy's offer to hold elections after a 60-day full ceasefire, and Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov's dismissive response, will show whether Trump's remark shifts the talks at all.
Regional Perspective
In Ukraine, the Kyiv Independent's Abbey Fenbert reported that Ukrainian negotiators felt blindsided, describing Miami talks they expected to produce a mutual energy ceasefire as "a trap," and noted Zelenskyy called the diesel deal "a weak decision by our strong partners." LIGA.net stressed that Ukrainian law forbids elections under martial law and that debate over future candidates is on hold until the war ends. In Russia, EADaily reported Kirill Dmitriev's post calling Trump's statement "An iconic and historical moment," and Meduza quoted Dmitry Peskov saying Zelenskyy has so far not shown the political will to end the war. European capitals moved quickly. Reuters, via The Star, reported that German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul said Germany would "fully support the President" and called for more pressure on Putin. Meduza reported statements of support from Britain and from Emmanuel Macron, and the Washington Post reported Donald Tusk's pledge of solidarity. Western US coverage centered on fuel prices and the midterms, while European and Ukrainian outlets centered on Zelenskyy's legitimacy and the Russian strikes that killed 20 people in Zaporizhzhia the same day, as Al Jazeera reported. For Ukraine, the stakes are practical: a US call for new leadership mirrors Moscow's argument that Zelenskyy's mandate has lapsed, and it came alongside US pressure to halt refinery strikes that Kyiv sees as one of its few levers. For Germany and Poland, the episode raised the cost of keeping sanctions in place while Washington eases them.