Washington rejects Justice Department demand to set aside ballots from 405 alleged noncitizens
Washington's top election official refused a federal demand to hold ballots from 405 people the Justice Department calls noncitizens.
Objective Facts
Federal prosecutors in Washington state sent Secretary of State Steve Hobbs a letter on Oct. 26 asking him not to verify or tabulate midterm ballots from 405 people they allege are noncitizens, until their citizenship is confirmed. Acting U.S. Attorney Neil Floyd said those people cast roughly 1,500 ballots in past elections and that the true number of noncitizen voters is in the thousands, though he did not release supporting evidence. Hobbs answered on Oct. 28, the Justice Department's deadline, and refused, writing that the list includes U.S. citizens, many people who are not active registered voters, and duplicate records delivered as a PDF without voter ID numbers or addresses. The Justice Department had warned it would seek emergency relief, but no lawsuit had been reported by Oct. 28. A similar federal demand over about 20,000 ballots in California is being fought in federal court.
Left-Leaning Perspective
Democracy Docket, the voting rights news site, covered the story twice. Jacob Knutson wrote on Oct. 26 that prosecutors made their claims without evidence eight days before Election Day, and Yunior Rivas reported on Oct. 28 that Hobbs's review found citizens on the list and that withholding their ballots would, in Hobbs's words, be illegal. NewsOne's Joe Jurado leaned on Associated Press reporting and argued in his closing section that the federal court fights are meant to stoke distrust among Donald Trump's supporters rather than to win.
Right-Leaning Perspective
Jason Rantz of Seattle Red 770 AM broke the story with an interview in which Floyd said some people on the list had voted several dozen times, and he set Floyd's 405 against Hobbs's count of 15 documented cases since 1982. The conservative Washington newsletter The Roundup, written by Nancy D Churchill, built its lead item on that contrast and quoted Sen. Rand Paul. The WLT Report took a more measured line, saying the list is unverified but demanding a full public accounting of each name.
Deep Dive
The Washington letter follows a near-identical demand in California, where the Justice Department asked officials to hold ballots from about 20,000 people and then sued; a federal appeals court declined on Oct. 26 to block California's count before a district judge rules. Washington mails a ballot to every registered voter, and ballots went out by Oct. 16, so the federal request arrived after voting had begun. Earlier this year a federal judge ruled against the Justice Department's lawsuit seeking Washington's unredacted voter file, which Floyd says forced agents to build the list by hand from immigration interviews and public data. Hobbs's critique of the list is specific and checkable: missing identifiers, duplicates, inactive or unregistered names, and a wrong election date in the cover letter. Those points weaken the case for holding ballots, but he has not yet said how many citizens he found, and his review was preliminary. Floyd's broader claim of thousands of noncitizen voters rests on extrapolation he has not documented, and past federal estimates in Nevada and Maricopa County shrank sharply under review, according to the AP. Neither side's public statements yet settle how many of the 405 are actually ineligible. The next steps are a possible Justice Department request for emergency relief in federal court, the second list prosecutors have promised before Nov. 3, and Hobbs's promised count of citizens found on the first list. Any criminal charges would come later; Floyd told KOMO it is too early to say. The outcome of the California case before a federal district judge in Los Angeles may shape how a Washington court treats a similar request. Southwest Washington's 3rd District, held by Democrat Marie Gluesenkamp Perez, is among the most competitive House races in the country, which raises the political weight of any fight over which ballots count.