White House withdraws Lance Schroyer's nomination to lead ICE

The White House pulled Lance Schroyer's ICE nomination without explanation after Sen. Rand Paul declined to schedule a hearing.

Objective Facts

The White House withdrew the nomination of Lance Schroyer to lead US Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Thursday, September 17, 2026, posting the notice on its website without explanation, according to the AP and States Newsroom. Donald Trump nominated Schroyer, a nearly 30-year Oklahoma law enforcement veteran who once ran Markwayne Mullin's Senate security detail, on June 27, but the nomination stalled in the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee. Chair Rand Paul had refused to schedule a hearing until DHS answered his questions about the investigation into the January killings of Renee Good and Alex Pretti by federal immigration officers in Minneapolis, VOZ and The Daily Wire reported. Paul said he learned of the withdrawal when it was made public, and the White House has not said when it will name a replacement for acting director David Venturella.

Left-Leaning Perspective

Mainstream left outlets presented the withdrawal as another setback for a turbulent Department of Homeland Security. NPR's Sergio Martínez-Beltrán noted that the pick was pulled less than three months after it was announced, that critics had repeatedly cited Schroyer's lack of immigration enforcement experience, and that DHS has lost several top leaders this year. ABC News' Luke Barr reported that both Trump's base and Democrats had questioned Schroyer's qualifications.

Right-Leaning Perspective

Right-leaning outlets framed the withdrawal as a Republican standoff and a judgment on Mullin. Colorado Politics, part of the Washington Examiner's network, headlined that the White House rescinded the nomination after Paul blocked it, and quoted an unnamed official calling the pick a mistake because of Schroyer's thin management record and closeness to Mullin. VOZ's Joaquín Núñez explained the Senate deadlock through Paul's oversight demands and doubts inside DHS about Schroyer's experience.

Deep Dive

Trump nominated Schroyer on June 27, aiming to give ICE its first Senate-confirmed director since the Obama administration. Schroyer rose to major in the Oklahoma Highway Patrol, helped set up the state's 287(g) partnership with ICE and led Mullin's Senate security detail before becoming a senior adviser at DHS, according to States Newsroom and The Daily Wire. Mullin became DHS secretary in March after a 54-45 confirmation vote, The National News Desk reported. The nomination stalled because Paul wanted answers on the January deaths of Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis, and ICE leadership had already turned over in May when Todd Lyons stepped down. The left-leaning focus on Schroyer's inexperience is backed by reporting across the spectrum, including Reuters, VOZ and The Daily Wire, so it is not a partisan claim. Left-leaning coverage gave less attention to the fact that the decisive obstacle was a Republican chair, and that Paul said he had no personal objection. Right-leaning coverage, for its part, mostly treated the episode as an internal fight over Mullin and gave little space to the civilian deaths that prompted Paul's request. Without a White House explanation, the specific reason for the withdrawal is still unknown. The White House has not said when it will name another nominee, and acting director David Venturella remains in charge. Open questions include whether DHS will give Paul the investigation update he requested, whether a new nominee would face the same hold, and how Mullin's standing is affected by losing a pick widely reported as his own.

OBJ SPEAKING

Create StoryTimelinesVoter ToolsRegional AnalysisPolicy GuideAll StoriesCommunity PicksUSWorldPoliticsBusinessHealthEntertainmentTechnologyAbout

White House withdraws Lance Schroyer's nomination to lead ICE

The White House pulled Lance Schroyer's ICE nomination without explanation after Sen. Rand Paul declined to schedule a hearing.

Sep 18, 2026
What's Going On
  • The White House withdrew Lance Schroyer's nomination to lead US Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Thursday, September 17, 2026, in a brief website notice that gave no reason, the AP and ABC News reported.
  • Schroyer, a former Oklahoma state trooper and senior adviser to Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin, was nominated in June but never received a hearing before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee.
  • Committee chair Rand Paul, a Kentucky Republican, held off on a hearing until DHS updated him on its investigation into civilian deaths in ICE operations, including two US citizens killed in Minneapolis, and told the AP he had no concern about the nominee himself.
  • ICE has had no Senate-confirmed director since the Obama administration; David Venturella, a former private prison executive, is acting director, and the White House has not named a new nominee.
  • Reuters reported that two US officials called Schroyer a surprise pick with little immigration experience, and The Daily Wire, citing other outlets, reported that border czar Tom Homan opposed the nomination.
Far Left: Democracy Now framed the story around Schroyer's inexperience and closeness to Mullin.
Left: NPR tied the withdrawal to Mullin's effort to distance himself from contested operations in Chicago and Minneapolis while ICE arrests hit a record.
Moderate: The AP reported that ICE arrests reached nearly 51,000 in August, the highest monthly total of Trump's second term.
Right: Colorado Politics reported that Paul has been highly critical of Mullin's leadership at DHS and that the White House had earlier denied Mullin picked Schroyer.
Far Right: The Daily Wire focused on Republican and administration objections rather than Democratic ones.
✓ Common Ground
Outlets from NPR to The Daily Wire reported doubts about whether Schroyer's state trooper background prepared him to run ICE, and ABC News said both Trump's base and Democrats had raised the issue.
Coverage across the spectrum treated Rand Paul's demand for answers on the Minneapolis killings as a legitimate oversight request, and none of the outlets reviewed disputed his account that it was not personal.
Several outlets, including the AP and Colorado Politics, noted that ICE has gone without a Senate-confirmed director for roughly a decade, a gap that spans administrations of both parties.
◆ All Sources (10)
AP via ABC7 - Trump withdraws Lance Schroyer, a former Oklahoma state trooper, as his nominee to lead ICEAl Jazeera (Reuters and AP) - White House withdraws Lance Schroyer's nomination to lead ICEGovernment Executive (States Newsroom) - ICE chief nominee's path to Senate confirmation ends abruptlyNPR via Connecticut Public - White House withdraws nomination of Lance Schroyer to lead ICEABC News via Good Morning America - White House withdraws nomination of Lance Schroyer as ICE directorDemocracy Now - White House Withdraws Nomination of Lance Schroyer to Lead ICEColorado Politics - White House rescinds ICE director nomination after Rand Paul blocks itVOZ - Trump withdraws his pick to lead ICE: The reasons behind the Senate deadlockThe Daily Wire - White House Withdraws ICE Director NomineeThe National News Desk via WJLA - ICE director nominee gets pulled by White House
Objective Deep Dive

Trump nominated Schroyer on June 27, aiming to give ICE its first Senate-confirmed director since the Obama administration. Schroyer rose to major in the Oklahoma Highway Patrol, helped set up the state's 287(g) partnership with ICE and led Mullin's Senate security detail before becoming a senior adviser at DHS, according to States Newsroom and The Daily Wire. Mullin became DHS secretary in March after a 54-45 confirmation vote, The National News Desk reported. The nomination stalled because Paul wanted answers on the January deaths of Renee Good and Alex Pretti in Minneapolis, and ICE leadership had already turned over in May when Todd Lyons stepped down.

The left-leaning focus on Schroyer's inexperience is backed by reporting across the spectrum, including Reuters, VOZ and The Daily Wire, so it is not a partisan claim. Left-leaning coverage gave less attention to the fact that the decisive obstacle was a Republican chair, and that Paul said he had no personal objection. Right-leaning coverage, for its part, mostly treated the episode as an internal fight over Mullin and gave little space to the civilian deaths that prompted Paul's request. Without a White House explanation, the specific reason for the withdrawal is still unknown.

The White House has not said when it will name another nominee, and acting director David Venturella remains in charge. Open questions include whether DHS will give Paul the investigation update he requested, whether a new nominee would face the same hold, and how Mullin's standing is affected by losing a pick widely reported as his own.

◈ Tone Comparison

Left-leaning outlets such as NPR called the withdrawal a setback for DHS and stressed Schroyer's inexperience and the Minneapolis killings. Right-leaning outlets such as VOZ and Colorado Politics wrote of a Senate deadlock and a blocked nominee, casting the episode as a fight between Paul and Mullin. Wire reports kept to the fact that the White House gave no reason.